Ice ream sandwiches are going to a whole new level with this Double Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream sammie situation! Forget about bikini season, it’s ice cream sandwich season in these parts!
Let’s talk about the components of these ice cream sandwiches.
First, the ice cream. You can certainly use your favorite store-bought chocolate ice cream, but I highly recommend making your own! This is my go-to, most favorite chocolate ice cream recipe. You may remember it from last summer, when I loaded it up with crushed Oreo cookies…..gosh, that was a good one. This recipe is everything I love about chocolate ice cream. It’s a super creamy (think frozen pudding), rich, dark chocolate explosion.
Shame on me for not sharing these peanut butter cookies with you sooner! Sorry, friends. What better to pair with my go-to chocolate ice cream, than my go-to peanut butter cookies. Right?! These cookies. It took every single ounce of willpower not to eat one off the baking sheet as they came out of the oven.
Once you’ve got the chocolate ice cream perfectly squashed between two soft peanut butter cookies, you can go ahead and dive right. Orrrrrrr…..you can dip your ice cream sammies in melted dark chocolate (yes, please!) and coat them with even more peanut-y goodness. You choose. Although, you really don’t want to miss out on the chocolate coating!
Disclosure: This post container affiliate links.